Grand Unified Theory on Bid'ah
Im going to turn off comments on this post, as I cba to debate and this post is not about debating the evidences of the different poistions, but on the issue of definitions.
As we all know we love debating the concept of bid'ah. Its a good debate as everyone has evidence that supports their views and it is all seemingly contradictory.
The basic argument is over two views on Bid'ah - One group says that bid'ah hasanah exists, the other says it doesnt. One says all Bid'ah is bad while the other says only bid'ah sayyi'ah is bad.
So its all irreconcileable.
Or is it?
In the grand scheme of things, from my understanding there are two popular positions on Bid'ah:
Position 1 as AFAIK supported by Imam Shafi'i:
