I have noticed a slight change in Ed too...

I think that thing with Med and all the blasphemous screwing around from Judda and Mujahid might be testing his endurance. Then of course there is the magazine...

This is merely a forum - not a model for international government. We shouldn't demand perfect evenhandedness at all times from the administrators, they are afterall human.

"Admin" wrote:

Quote:

All Muslim Jurists agree that sodomy is a sexual offence but they differ in the punishment. It is reported by Abu Hurairah (Rahmatullaahi Alayh) that the Messenger of Allah Ta’ala (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) said: " If you find someone who is committing an act of the people of Lut (i.e. homosexuality), kill the one on top and the one below", and in another statement it says " kill the doer and the one with whom the act is committed." (Tirmidhi, Baihaqi, Abu Dawood)

You can't just throw a hadith at us.

Give us the scholarly context.

"Constantine" wrote:

This is merely a forum - not a model for international government. We shouldn't demand perfect evenhandedness at all times from the administrators, they are afterall human.

Exactly, it's just an online forum.. .there's no need for him to be getting out of his pram so often

first line is the scholarly context. they disagree with the exact punishment...

I got that from:

http://www.jamiat.org.za/aljamiat/march2002/al_jamiat_march_2002.htm

I have no idea how legit they are, but Shaykh Google reccomended them to me as the first link...

"Aphrodite" wrote:

"Constantine" wrote:

This is merely a forum - not a model for international government. We shouldn't demand perfect evenhandedness at all times from the administrators, they are afterall human.

Exactly, it's just an online forum.. .there's no need for him to be getting out of his pram so often

Oh i'm not saying it's right to fly off like that... but I certainly think if I were in the same circumstances I would be equally irritable.

I mean the guy has devoted a significant amount of his time and energy to a free website, magazine, and forum to promote his dearly beloved religion and he sees Judda coming on and lambasting that religion left right center up and down.

I just don't think I consider myself in a position to judge.

"Admin" wrote:

I have no idea how legit they are, but Shaykh Google reccomended them to me as the first link...

You know, taking Google™ as your shaykh isn't a good idea.

Ed are you quoting [url=http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_isla.htm]here[/url] when you gave your bit?

"Admin" wrote:

Ed are you quoting [url=http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_isla.htm]here[/url] when you gave your bit?

The Islamic Society of North America is dead right on that page

"Admin" wrote:

Ed are you quoting [url=http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_isla.htm]here[/url] when you gave your bit?

This webpage is a serious hotchpotch isn't it?

They even cite Al-Muhajiroon and Ahmadis.

Oh the dangers of Shaykh Google™. :roll:

"irfghan" wrote:

"Admin" wrote:

Ed are you quoting [url=http://www.religioustolerance.org/hom_isla.htm]here[/url] when you gave your bit?

This webpage is serious hotchpotch isn't it?

They even cite Al-Muhajiroon and Ahmadis.

Oh the dangers of Shaykh Google™. :roll:

Oiii! leave the shaykh alone!

:evil:

That whole site is like that.

A group of people seem to have got together and written alot on all the religions and cults they could find...

"Admin" wrote:

Oiii! leave the shaykh alone!

:evil:

That whole site is like that.

A group of people seem to have got together and written alot on all the religions and cults they could find...

Hardly reliable. :roll:

They have a bias.

They have no understanding of the faith.

They are giving bullet points, not detailed explanations.

Down with Shaykh Google™!!!

the Mods are only human

they aint infallible-nor were they sent from above with a divine message

we have one who's googled up in the head :twisted:

if they want to contribute (which they should)

they should be HONEST

naturally some of the crap that some crazy posters come out with is gonna make then mad-

not everyone can practise patience and self control-we're only human

judda budda makes most of us sick-he's stupid, dirty and blasphemous

he shoulda been banned time ago

I agree that he should be ignored and not responded to