Questions about Shias + free for all

malik —

i am shia muslim. dont hesatate to ask me any questions about shia islam. i dont know everything so. i am not an imam.
i get asked loads of qs in collage. sometimes i dont know the answers.

anyways.

Forum

You — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 00:57

Naah. Let keep it going.

I am not gonna moderate this topic.

I (well, another mod whose decision I supported...) have already been overruled once...

I will butt out of moderating this topic, as has been asked for.

Dave — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 00:59

Now is STILL A SPLENDID TIME TO STOP PICKING ON LILSIS - HURLING CHARGES OF EXTREMISM AT ONE ANOTHER AND NOT COMING TO ANY HARD CONCLUSIONS.

Cake break!

I command you all to go forth - invade your cupboards, go to bakeries, or just make cake at home.

You'll all be much happier when you've had cake.

I assure you.

MuslimSisLilSis — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:00

[quote="Don Karnage"]Now is STILL A SPLENDID TIME TO STOP PICKING ON LILSIS - HURLING CHARGES OF EXTREMISM AT ONE ANOTHER AND NOT COMING TO ANY HARD CONCLUSIONS.

.[/quote]

Your the Man Dave

thankyou for the life ring

I was drowing there 😉

Dave — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:03

[quote="Admin"]Naah. Let keep it going.

I am not gonna moderate this topic.

I (well, another mod whose decision I supported...) have already been overruled once...

I will butt out of moderating this topic, as has been asked for.[/quote]

Admin clearly nothing good is coming of this topic.

LilSis does not sign onto this forum to have people accuse her relatives of apostacy, and Med doesn't sign on to be compared to regimes noted for their brutality.

This simply has gone too far - it's gotten personal and where precisely are we learning anything new?

You all are simply shouting the same points to each other - in louder more ridiculous font sizes. That's not a discussion, nor is it a debate - and I am very much afraid that it's only going to further divide people up.

Clearly this is a situation which deserves special attention from you.

MuslimSisLilSis — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:03

[quote="Omrow"]Does that mean we can bring guns ? And Marijuana ?[/quote]

why not-

as shown by the links Fred provided guns are much needed in this topic

and u can bring the weed too-I was recently told that brewli's like to have a puff now and again

*DUST* — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:03

[quote="Don Karnage"]Now is STILL A SPLENDID TIME TO STOP PICKING ON LILSIS - HURLING CHARGES OF EXTREMISM AT ONE ANOTHER AND NOT COMING TO ANY HARD CONCLUSIONS.[/quote]
i wasnt doing any of that^ was i? :?

Dave — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:04

[quote="Omrow"]Don. Butt out. This is muslim on muslim fight. Just stand and watch.[/quote]

Omrow, all you've been doing for the last five minutes is fanning the flames and sitting back to watch "the fight" - as you so aptly put.

I don't need to be a muslim to see when "debates" aren't debates or when they get personal - that simply requires common sense.

You — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:04

Omrow, my statement was there so that if i am wrong someone can prove it.

I made it saying that it is a sin, ut not kufr as far as I am aware, as my knowledge is not absolute. I can and do make mistakes.

Now if I am wrong prove it.

Med you have made sone ASSUMPTIONS in your argument. One was pointed out by Dust. There are others aswell.

I stand by my position on what our position should be. everything else is just there for the sake of it.

think of the story about the colour of that dog...

Omrow — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:07

[quote="Don Karnage"]Omrow, all you've been doing for the last five minutes is fanning the flames and sitting back to watch "the fight" - as you so aptly put.

I don't need to be a muslim to see when "debates" aren't debates or when they get personal - that simply requires common sense.[/quote]

That's not so common here. We have a mad Med the Wahhabi here.

Tongue twister he is.

*DUST* — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 01:18

[quote="Omrow"]Admin. Free what?

Can you add: FREE DRUGS[/quote]
omrow,

shoo. go on, get out of here. children are not welcome in adults' discussion.

goodbye!

:roll: 😛

Beast — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 10:21

Seeing as this thread will not be moderated, I am going to take decisive action.

Nobody get in my way. :evil:

Unless you want to join in. 😃

MuslimSisLilSis — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 10:45

LOL

what pwetty pictures

it downplays the danger and arrognace of accusing Muslims of being KAFIR

I attended a Muhurrum programme last year in my sunni mosque-they had invited a shia imam to chat about karbala

we might do the same again

the haters should learn sumin from them :roll:

so me and u here will spend our time trying to maintain unity

whilst the fanatics can do the opposite

post some more pwetty pictures up 😉

malik — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 10:49

why are people fighting against me. im not swearing at anyone. i just saying these are my beliefs.

I said before we don't believe Quran has been tempered at all. I have same Quran as every other Muslim. I believe our books of Hadith have many errors in them. Quran has no errors, it is same Quran as what Prophet pbuhff gave to Imam Ali. About sahabas, we see most of them as ordinary muslims. there are few special sahabas who didnt disobey the prophet pbhuhhf and we love them more than anyone else, the rest were weak like me and you. they sometimes didnt obey orders of Prophet pbuhhf. i agree with admin what he said about what is Muslim. to become Muslim you have to believe in six things. and i do believe in these things Allah Angels Prophets Books Day of jeudgement and Qada wal Qadr. belief in all sahabas is not necessary.

some sister reminded me to answer last part of admins q.

mutah cannot be abused as prostitution. its is like normal marriage except there is a time fixed at start for divorce. then woman waits iddah before she can marry again. propstitutes dont wait.

Beast — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 10:53

[quote="malik"]why are people fighting against me. im not swearing at anyone. i just saying these are my beliefs.

I said before we don't believe Quran has been tempered at all. I have same Quran as every other Muslim. I believe our books of Hadith have many errors in them. Quran has no errors, it is same Quran as what Prophet pbuhff gave to Imam Ali. About sahabas, we see most of them as ordinary muslims. there are few special sahabas who didnt disobey the prophet pbhuhhf and we love them more than anyone else, the rest were weak like me and you. they sometimes didnt obey orders of Prophet pbuhhf. i agree with admin what he said about what is Muslim. to become Muslim you have to believe in six things. and i do believe in these things Allah Angels Prophets Books Day of jeudgement and Qada wal Qadr. belief in all sahabas is not necessary.[/quote]

That's not gonna convince any of the Wahabbi-loving haters.

malik — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 11:09

im trying to answer qs. i dont fight or insult peple. Imam Ali said my shias do not insult beliefs of other people. I respect sunnis beliefs which i know to be wrong. i cant convinve people. Prophet pbuhhf could not convinve some people. we have our beliefs and others have their own beliefs. im not preaching. i know lots of people hate Shias because they cant sit and talk to shias. they fear truth might come out and shake their weak propoganda.

Dave — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 13:46

[quote="malik"]why are people fighting against me. im not swearing at anyone. i just saying these are my beliefs.

I said before we don't believe Quran has been tempered at all. I have same Quran as every other Muslim. I believe our books of Hadith have many errors in them. Quran has no errors, it is same Quran as what Prophet pbuhff gave to Imam Ali. About sahabas, we see most of them as ordinary muslims. there are few special sahabas who didnt disobey the prophet pbhuhhf and we love them more than anyone else, the rest were weak like me and you. they sometimes didnt obey orders of Prophet pbuhhf. i agree with admin what he said about what is Muslim. to become Muslim you have to believe in six things. and i do believe in these things Allah Angels Prophets Books Day of jeudgement and Qada wal Qadr. belief in all sahabas is not necessary.[/quote]

Actually most of the people here were defending you...

MuslimSister — Mon, 9 Jan 2006 - 13:58

[quote="Don Karnage"]

Actually most of the people here were defending you...[/quote]

Yes, but insults are always louder then nice words.

I too would only focus on the personal attacks in this thread.