is singing allowed?? without the music!

MastKuri โ€”

[color=blue][/color]

ive heard loads of things regarding this subject and i just wanted to hear your opinions too,
my aunty who is an alima says your aloud to sing songs without the music,and i dont mean islamic nasheeds..i mean bollywood songs etc

is it allowed or not?
and why?

Forum

MuslimSisLilSis โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 17:42

[quote="Omrow"]Salam

Well, Masti girl, its the people who say that a particular thing is UNLAWFUL, it is those people that need to get off their butt and show that the thing is indeed unlawful.

It is NEVER up to the people who do something to prove that their action are lawful.

This is not Russia. This is Britain. GREAT BRITAIN.

[/quote]

couldnt have said it better myself

looks like u've already started on ur mission-I'll help u if u ever need it

but bear in mind-sumtimes its like bashing ur head against a brick wall

good luck

8)

MastKuri โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 21:29

[quote="Med"][quote="naj"]

LOL, u know what lilsis sometimes ur sarcy remarks make me laugh..thanx i need cheering up..[/quote]

I think the above post sufficiently describes what I think.[/quote]

gosh i dont blame u guys

Alisha โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 22:44

I've been told people are allowed to (not in front of the opposite gender) and the words cant be dirty/abusive/or about drugs/drink/killing ect as for bollywood songs hmmmmmm people have to think "what is this teaching us, are we benefitting from this" Allahu Alam, Allah knows best ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

equanimity โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 22:49

salaam , music is haram you only need to go to a club to see the effects of music which leads to drugs, intermixing, sex, fighting . Anyone who listens to bollywood music should know bollywood helps fund the indian army and promoton of love relationships and hippop music promotes violence and drugs whereas pop music promotes intermixing and dancing. The only music considered halal is music that promotes islam and encourages good . I am guilty as i regurly listen to hippop music but im making an concious effort to stop so should we all. However we have to put it into context although music is bad it is a minor we should concentrate on stopping our other sins e.g. missing namaz.

MuslimSisLilSis โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 22:51

so in other words

open msg to all the freshies out there

no more pulling out bollywood lyrics to ur wives

cos according to SOME people (whom I disagree with)

music is HARAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM

Seraphim โ€” Thu, 13 Oct 2005 - 23:12

[quote="MuslimSisLilSis"]so in other words

open msg to all the freshies out there

no more pulling out bollywood lyrics to ur wives

cos according to SOME people (whom I disagree with)

music is HARAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM[/quote]

I wasnt aware people actually did that???

Lame... lack of originality... to show her he loves her he rips of a bolly song.

lol... lameo.

star โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 00:47

[quote="MastKuri"][quote="Med"][quote="naj"]

LOL, u know what lilsis sometimes ur sarcy remarks make me laugh..thanx i need cheering up..[/quote]

I think the above post sufficiently describes what I think.[/quote]

gosh i dont blame u guys[/quote]

saf i clearly advice u to ask aisha apa peerbhai....she"ll tell u straight,
believe your ustaads. i dunno if u still remember how dun we'd get for singing, and then them bollywood nasheeds were banned.

You โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 00:58

nowt wrong wit singing in private... if the material is acceptable. If in company, it again depends on the company... and again the material.

If you must sing... try a few arabic nasheeds.... Tala'al Badru is very good...

You do not have to sing modern pap.

Angel โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 12:35

[quote="naj"]yea angel, they were good lyrics sung in bollywood tunes...apparently they were banned for us 2 listen 2, maybe that waz a good thing.[/quote]

So why are they called bollywood "nasheeds" surely if they were also suposed to be wrong (even if they have good lyrics) then they should be categorised as just bollywood songs and not "nasheeds", that to me seems a bit odd.

Btw isnt "nasheed" meant to refer to islamic material, first i have heard of these bollywood "nasheeds"

MastKuri โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 13:46

the thing is angel the nasheeds were bollywood songs without the music,just a few wordings here and there were changed,most of the lyrics were exactly the same as the bollywood song,i think thats why they were banned from jamis,we use to sing the song instead of the nasheed!

star โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 14:39

[quote="MastKuri"]the thing is angel the nasheeds were bollywood songs without the music,just a few wordings here and there were changed,most of the lyrics were exactly the same as the bollywood song,i think thats why they were banned from jamis,we use to sing the song instead of the nasheed![/quote]

lol u did...

Angel โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 14:46

[quote="MastKuri"][quote="Med"][quote="naj"]

LOL, u know what lilsis sometimes ur sarcy remarks make me laugh..thanx i need cheering up..[/quote]

I think the above post sufficiently describes what I think.[/quote]

gosh i dont blame u guys[/quote]

me too :roll: since everyone is agreeing.......lilsis does bring a smile to ppl's faces what can i say she's got a sense of humour....go lilsis ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

Neway must dash to work. ws

MuslimSisLilSis โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 17:04

[quote="angel"]

me too :roll: since everyone is agreeing.......lilsis does bring a smile to ppl's faces what can i say she's got a sense of humour....go lilsis ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

Neway must dash to work. ws[/quote]

thats what I'm here for

i go out of my way to be jokey and funny-

99% of the time I'm never serious

but whats intresting to note is that some of the clowns here are funny and make me laugh even though they dont mean to

imagine that -being a joker and cracking others up with the rubbish they come out with without even meaning to :shock:

:twisted:

equanimity โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 22:59

all you bollywood lovers out there, yeah im talking to all those cape/aston/alum rock/small heath pakies stop blasting bollywood songs they sound crap

Sirus โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 23:23

[quote="Raf786"]all you bollywood lovers out there, yeah im talking to all those cape/aston/alum rock/small heath pakies stop blasting bollywood songs they sound crap[/quote]

lol, u tell em!

btw - ive heard what masti is goin on about.......theyre the background to famous bollywood songs, but islamic words. i dont really approve of this myself. but they are very rare anyway, and i doubt anyone really listens to them

Beast โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 23:25

[quote="Darth V-Hayder"]
btw - ive heard what masti is goin on about.......theyre the background to famous bollywood songs, but islamic words. i dont really approve of this myself. but they are very rare anyway, and i doubt anyone really listens to them[/quote]

There's this video to a Bollywood song which is set i na strip joint. (I hear)

One of the lines in the song is 'tere sajde mein mera ye sar hai'.

Sirus โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 23:29

[quote="irfghan"][quote="Darth V-Hayder"]
btw - ive heard what masti is goin on about.......theyre the background to famous bollywood songs, but islamic words. i dont really approve of this myself. but they are very rare anyway, and i doubt anyone really listens to them[/quote]

There's this video to a Bollywood song which is set i na strip joint. (I hear)

One of the lines in the song is 'tere sajde mein mera ye sar hai'.[/quote]

that could mean anything

nothing to do with islam

possibly trickks from the dodgy hindu's in the industry

the Dil Se song, chayya chayya had statements like.....cant remember, but they were to do with Islam

MuslimSisLilSis โ€” Fri, 14 Oct 2005 - 23:31

[quote="Darth V-Hayder"]

the Dil Se song, chayya chayya had statements like.....cant remember, but they were to do with Islam[/quote]

yeh I remember that

they had two versions of that song

one was a blasphemous one and the other one was non blasphemous

i think they lifted it from nusrat fateh ali khan

MastKuri โ€” Mon, 17 Oct 2005 - 14:39

[quote="naj"][quote="MastKuri"]the thing is angel the nasheeds were bollywood songs without the music,just a few wordings here and there were changed,most of the lyrics were exactly the same as the bollywood song,i think thats why they were banned from jamis,we use to sing the song instead of the nasheed![/quote]

lol u did...[/quote]

:oops:

star โ€” Mon, 17 Oct 2005 - 15:00

were all duff nazams banned?

whats this hadith about.

ibn mas'ood narrates the prophet s.a.w saying,
"singing sprouts hypocrisy in the heart as rain sprouts plants"

MastKuri โ€” Mon, 17 Oct 2005 - 15:08

[quote="naj"]were all duff nazams banned?

whats this hadith about.

ibn mas'ood narrates the prophet s.a.w saying,
"singing sprouts hypocrisy in the heart as rain sprouts plants"[/quote]

yes i think they were naj,remember the really famous one that all the jamia girls loved..that mere sonia madine which rehn waleya!!
i want that nazam have you got it????

errm dont know what it means!!

ALquds โ€” Mon, 17 Oct 2005 - 16:08

the heartbeat has a rhythem rite?? well the rhythem of the dhaf shoudnt be too fast... duno she can sing to me anything as long as i can laugh at her silly