Why We Cry
I could not explain it before as to why we cry, but I think this scientific research helps us to expain why we Shias mourn everyyear for the tragic death of Imam Hussain.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20070617/hl_nm/empathy_dc
[quote]
[b]Study may explain roots of empathy [/b]
By Julie Steenhuysen - Sun Jun 17, 2007
When people say "I feel your pain," they do not mean it literally, but certain people really do feel something that appears to be an extreme form of empathy, British researchers said on Sunday.
They said watching someone being touched triggers the same part of the brain as actual touch, and this connection helps explain how we understand what other people are feeling.
People who experience a tactile sense of touch when they see another person being touched -- something called mirror-touch synesthesia -- was first studied in 2005 in one person.
But researchers at University College London have now studied 10 people with the same condition.
"It suggests there is a link between certain aspects of the tactile system and empathy," said Michael Banissy of the university's department of psychology, whose work appears in the journal Nature Neuroscience.
Banissy and colleagues first did a series of experiments to authenticate peoples' claims that they felt something when they saw someone else being touched.
They asked the 10 people with mirror-touch synesthesia to identify when they were being touched on their own body while watching someone else being touched on the cheek.
The actual touch was sometimes in the same spot as the person they watched being touched, and sometimes it was on the other side.
"The idea was to see whether synesthetic and actual touch were confusable in any way," Banissy said in a telephone interview.
He said people with this mirror-touch capability were faster when the touch they saw was in the same location as actual touch.
"When actual touch and synesthetic touch were in different locations, sometimes they would confuse the two and report they were touched on both cheeks," he said.
This confusion did not occur in 20 people without synesthesia who performed the same experiments.
The mirror-touch people also scored higher than others on a questionnaire that measured empathy.
"We often flinch when we see someone knock their arm, and this may be a weaker version of what these synesthetes experience," Dr. Jamie Ward, who led the research team, said in a statement.
Other studies have suggested a link between empathy and mirror systems, but Ward said this was the first to suggest empathy involves more than one mechanism: an emotional gut reaction -- which appears exaggerated in the mirror-touch synesthetes -- and a cognitive process that involves thinking about how someone else feels.
"This appears to be the emotional component of empathy," Banissy said. "It was purely gut instinct."
One of the mirror-touch subjects in the study said the experience is all she has ever known.
"It is -- to me at least -- a perfectly normal response to seeing touch or pain inflicted on another person," she said in a statement.
The researchers are studying this empathy connection further and trying to determine how prevalent mirror-touch synesthesia is.
"It does appear to be more common than we first thought," Banissy said.
[/quote]
I think Christians do remember Jesus, peace be upon him, and his brutal crucifixion at Easter.
But I don't think they cry for him every year.
Maybe they dont love him as they claim they do.
If you love someone, then surely you would weep for them.
[b]Do any of you here on the Revival cry for someone regularly?[/b]
Why We Cry
Why We Cry
[quote="malik"]It is said that true believers all will do matam for Imam Hussain on the Day on Judgement. Men women anc children will cry for Imam Hussain for a long time. Angels and Prophet will all mourn for Imam Hussain on that day. We believe they even today they cry for Imam Hussain in the sky. Imam Mehdi and Jesus Christ are coming back to this earth and they will conduct jaloos and lead matami tolas everywhere. [/quote]
Once again Malik, prove it with Quran and Hadith!!!
Why We Cry
i think ur missing the point of asking him to proove it with qur'an and hadith. he's not a scholar for one thing. and many sunni people do things that have no basis in quran and sunnah and we manage to accept differences.
i wasn't asking him to make him proove/disproove his beliefs, i was merely trying to understand actual shia beliefs from th inside (instead of the propaganda u hear in mosques about baby-eating etc).
Why We Cry
Obviously we have our own ulema who tell us things from the Holy Quran and from books of hadith.
I cant remember all the references because I am not a scholar. I have given some sources about my beliefs but if you want to know all the rest then I suggest you ask a proper Shia Alim.
There are a lof of things about matam and mourning for Imam Hussain that we are taught in Muharram. I cant remember everything that is told. I just get on with doing the matam and zanjeer when our scholars lead us in the jaloos on the streets.
Everybody has their own beliefs and practices. We Shias might seems a little strange to others but that is what we do. It is our belief which is based on Islamic teachings.
[quote="malik"] Angels and Prophet will all mourn for Imam Hussain on that day. [/quote]
Im a little confused why is it that the Angels and Prophet will mourn for Imam Hussain P.B.U.H.? Why not mourn for other relatives of the prophet?