British Gay And Muslim

MuslimSister

Gay Muslims

This Channel 4 documentary shows how the experiences of five lesbian and gay Muslims in Britain challenge the heterosexual bias in Muslim communities and illustrate the diversity within Islam. Tamsila Tauqir reports

Over the sinister introductory music to the programme, presenter Sonia Deol says: ‘Islam is fierce in its condemnation of homosexuality.’ Let’s be fair, antagonism towards homosexuality is no more exclusive to any one community than favouring men, the able-bodied and those with wealth and power.

The activist

Some 200 lesbian and gay Muslims were contacted by the programme makers but only a handful were willing to be interviewed, and most of those insisted on keeping their identities hidden. Only one was prepared to show his face and give his true name. He was Adnan Ali, an activist on issues affecting lesbian, gay, bisexual and transsexual (LGBT) Muslims.
Adnan described how, when he first came out about his sexuality in Pakistan, he was physically and verbally abused. He then came to the UK, where he chatted online with members of the Al-fatiha Foundation in the States. Al-fatiha is an international organisation dedicated to questioning Muslims who are LGBT and their friends. Adnan then set-up a sister group called Al-fatiha UK, now called Imaan.

The voices
The interviewees speak of their commitment to and belief in Islam, though instead of having their beliefs supported by their community and family, they face being ostracised. ‘Razeem’ speaks of his pain at being denied access to the children of his previous marriage, despite having a legal right to access and the fact that his wife ran away with another man. He also wishes there were more role models, like Adnan Ali, for gay Muslims.

‘Shakir’ and his parents find it easier to accept lesbianism than gay men’s homosexuality. ‘Farah’ contemplates going back into the closet, to lie about her sexuality to ease the tension in her relationship with her parents. Presenter Sonia Deol says that the gay Muslim group, Imaan, supports the idea of ‘keeping sexuality a private matter’.

[b]MONDAY 23TH JANUARY CHANNEL FOUR 8PM[/b]

[url=http://www.channel4.com/culture/microsites/C/can_you_believe_it/debates…]

Forum

Beast — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 19:26

[quote="Don Karnage"][quote="MuslimSister"]*bump*[/quote]

did you trip?[/quote]

You make that joke everytime, Dave.

Dave — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 19:29

[quote="Beast"][quote="Don Karnage"][quote="MuslimSister"]*bump*[/quote]

did you trip?[/quote]

You make that joke everytime, Dave.[/quote]

:shock: I do?!

...i hope im not like the guy from memento

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:10

I dont know whether to laugh or cry.

Lets start off nice. In the beginning of the programme the voiceover chatting about one sodomite says that he got married . . . . to a woman. Sounds like a big shock!

And then towards end dum.b she does same thing to "Razeem" when he says he is gonna get married; and she goes summat like "to a woman?"

SPAS! Men get married to women.

And then the angry bit. That Adnan Devil's spawn says he want a nikaah with that sodomite and he wants to have Quran read at his "ceremony".

And worse, worst of ALL was that woman who wore a niqab at the london thing and said how Islam aint against sodomites. The woman said all that wearing a niqab, I hope her face burns. How dare she bad-naam the noble pure and holy veil by donning it and proclaiming her disciplship to lucifer the accursed?

I pray to ALLAH that those who have defamed and abused Islam die the death of dogs. May their faces be blackened, and in particular those who wore niqab and then proclaimed their discipleship to Iblees, may her face be filled with blisters, thenn may it be deformed and disgrace colour her in this world and in the eternity.

The issue aint with homos, I am incensed at their disrespect and mockery of religion. If she went with hair flowing and said rubbish it would have been bad; but wearing a Holy Veil and saying that. She has made people think that perhaps some women who wear veil are like her; ALLAH forgive us for the whisperings the devil and his cohorts put in our minds.

ameen.

May ALLAH protect the youth who are confused from being encouraged or instigated by these slaves of Satan and protect them and us from the nefarious plots of Lucifer and his cohorts. Ya ALLAH drown us in you mercy, and keep us safe from the fitnah that is enveloping the earth.

ameen Ya ALLAH, thumma Ameen.

[b]EDIT: -------------- Modnster [/b]

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:12

Salaam

Shocking…

What was more shocking was the fact that most of them didn’t even consider their homosexuality as a sin…

Being “gay and proud” is a whole different (worse) issue altogether….

But I don't agree with being ostracized from the community…cos this just makes them more well “gay”….If the community is cutting them off etc...then of course they're going to be running more so into the arms of those people they shouldnt be with...

I don’t agree with banning access to kids etc

But that was a really bad programme….

Wasalaam

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:15

:x :x :x :x :x :x :x :x :x

£$£$£"$"£%"%£$^£^£^£^£$¬!!!!!

AAAAAAAAARGGGGGGGGGGH :shock:

meeting in manchester piccadilly at 10pm, were heading straight to canal street aka gay village........beat some homo's up, especially 'muslim' ones

whos with me lol

man i feel vexxed BIG TIME

cant help it

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:18

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]

meeting in manchester piccadilly at 10pm, were heading straight to canal street aka gay village........beat some homo's up, especially 'muslim' ones

[/quote]

Will that make them "straight"?

Beast — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:23

Wasn't able to watch the programme, but that stuff about homosexuality being OK in Islam was to be expected.

Just look at Irshad Manji. She sees herself as an Islamic reformer but doesn't let the fact that she's lesbian get in the way. In fact she doesn't tire of telling people about it.

Even then, Muslim gays in the US have their own mosque(s) and imams.

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:24

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]no, but make me feel better :evil: :lol:[/quote]

bruv gimme a couple of hours, and i get there. BUT you gotta reciprocate and we cordially invite you to our outing in brum.

I totally disagree about the kids. It is imperative upon the mother and other relatives to keep the kids away from the devil and his followers. Would any1 agree to letting their kids going and playing with iblees as a baby-sitter? I dont think so ; so why let them go and play with iblees' devoted followers?

No, The children were rightly kept safe from it. And I feel for the woman who married that thing. And he was like: sniffs my wife left me and sniffs ran of sniff with another man.

Dirrty animal, was probably jealous that he wanted to go off with som1 instead. Disgusting.

bechare bachche. whose gonna wanna marry the kids of a homo? I feel so sorry for them.

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:24

The “lurgies” bit in the programme made me laugh….the the mum served her son in separate plates and cups.

I didn’t know that being homosexual is contagious.

It was bad that the entire programme just focused on being “gay and proud”. No emphasis was placed on seeking a cure for their perversion.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:26

[quote="Med"]
And he was like: sniffs my wife left me and sniffs ran of sniff with another man.

[/quote]

😂 😂

HAHA

chi chi man

he drank, he clubbed, he was gay, acts like a wuss, has hadith books piled up like as if hes a Shaykh and hes 5 time nimaazi

looooooooool

comical

May Allah SWT help us all

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:27

[quote="Med"] It is imperative upon the mother and other relatives to keep the kids away from the devil and his followers. Would any1 agree to letting their kids going and playing with iblees as a baby-sitter? I dont think so ; so why let them go and play with iblees' devoted followers?

No, The children were rightly kept safe from it. And I feel for the woman who married that thing. And he was like: sniffs my wife left me and sniffs ran of sniff with another man.

.[/quote]

The wife who committed adultery? I don’t think she’s any better then him.

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:27

Mufti Barkatullah disappointed me AGAIN unfortunately.

He should have condemned the homosexuality rather than trying to help him make contact with the kids. Im sorry but I dont need an alim to tell me that a sodomite should NOT be allowed near children; my imaan demands it.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:28

[quote="MuslimSister"]The “lurgies” bit in the programme made me laugh….the the mum served her son in separate plates and cups.

I didn’t know that being homosexual is contagious.

It was bad that the entire programme just focused on being “gay and proud”. No emphasis was placed on seeking a cure for their perversion.[/quote]

lol word to that

the parents - 1 said Lesbo's was ok (me thinks hes a horny guy) and the mum said it was genetic

gerr'off

these lot were ALL SUPPOSED TO BE practising

i dont believe it

they dont know what practising means :roll:

yes, i hate gay people

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:30

[quote="MuslimSister"]

The wife who committed adultery? I don’t think she’s any better then him.[/quote]

I dont condone her adulery. That is sin.

But, yeh , I think she is better than him. I sympathise with the poor mare; getting married to some geeza and not being husband and wife for 4 years cos he was a sodomite cant be easy.

Yeh, she made a mistake. May ALLAH forgive her and make her noble and righteous and us also. ameen.

But; I say it clearly, she is better than him.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:30

[quote="Med"]Mufti Barkatullah disappointed me AGAIN unfortunately.

He should have condemned the homosexuality rather than trying to help him make contact with the kids. Im sorry but I dont need an alim to tell me that a sodomite should NOT be allowed near children; my imaan demands it.[/quote]

he didnt do a great job, he was bieng more of the social counseller rather than an Imaam (altho u can be both)

BUT THEN AGAIN, he may have said more, not neccesarily got onto the show - they can cut things to suit thier needs

Sajid Iqbal — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:30

i will give my views on the programme later

now for those who ar egoing school, college, uni, work 2morrow.. get ready to answer, debate with non muslims....
we're gonna get 101 questions.... so be prepared..
i will try to post some articles on teh site tonight....

issues to bare in mind

1. is homosexuality genetic or not- no proof what so ever it is genetic
2. its a sickness just like incest, having sex with an animal, peodophillia etc... AS ALL OF THESE ACTS ARE ONES WHICH ONE CANNOT CONTROL THEIR DESIRES, WHERE OUR DESIRES BECOME FILTHY.
3. what islam says... emphasise on the fact that it is not normal, not natural, not purpose of sex, its harmful, damaging....an dtotally contradicts teachings of islam...
4. Homosexuality was illegal 40 years ago....now its ok...we dont change our morals and values...we get our morals from the Creator.
5. Gay Muslims need to speak to Islamic people, to have their questions answered, to get help, to get tarbiyyah, .... we need to face reality and help them ....

will post more points later...

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:33

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]

the parents - 1 said Lesbo's was ok (me thinks hes a horny guy) and the mum said it was genetic

gerr'off

these lot were ALL SUPPOSED TO BE practising

i dont believe it

they dont know what practising means :roll:

[/quote]

1. yeh, that bit made me laff. the dad saying tha stuff- well u aint too clued up are you? For the record female and male perversion IS equally evil and deviation.

2. When mother goes must be genetic I was cracking up agen. Thickos - that must mean one of you two passed on the homo gene. Spas!

3. Upon these people rests a curse. No matter how much Quran they read, they will remain under it so long as they perpertrate their crimes against God, the Prophets and Nature.

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:33

[quote="Med"]

I sympathise with the poor mare

But; I say it clearly, she is better than him.[/quote]

The punishment for adultery and homosexuality is death.

I have no sympathy for an adulterer and nor do I have any sympathy for a homosexual.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:34

thanx ed

theres too many in manchester, its like a gay capital

my mate got his backside touched up badly.....man, he was shocked for ages....bechara

once again..........

3$"£$"£5"£%$"£""£$£""!!!!

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:35

[quote="Med"][quote="Hayder on Holiday"]

the parents - 1 said Lesbo's was ok (me thinks hes a horny guy) and the mum said it was genetic

gerr'off

these lot were ALL SUPPOSED TO BE practising

i dont believe it

they dont know what practising means :roll:

[/quote]

1. yeh, that bit made me laff. the dad saying tha stuff- well u aint too clued up are you? For the record female and male perversion IS equally evil and deviation.

2. When mother goes must be genetic I was cracking up agen. Thickos - that must mean one of you two passed on the homo gene. Spas!

3. Upon these people rests a curse. No matter how much Quran they read, they will remain under it so long as they perpertrate their crimes against God, the Prophets and Nature.[/quote]

LOL @ THE GENETIC!!!

haha....fools

btw bro, dont say spas please - i think its insulting towards disabled people

not nice

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:36

[quote="MuslimSister"][quote="Med"]

I sympathise with the poor mare

But; I say it clearly, she is better than him.[/quote]

The punishment for adultery and homosexuality is death.

I have no sympathy for an adulterer and nor do I have any sympathy for a homosexual.[/quote]

The punishment is death indeed.

The adultery punishment is clear; the Sahabah Karaam were baffled in how to deal with the sodomites and how their mode of death was to be. Infact I can sympathise with the thief, the adulterer, the shaver, even the murderer. But the sodomite he has perverted his very essence. He is no longer a human.

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:38

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]
btw bro, dont say spas please - i think its insulting towards disabled people

not nice[/quote]

good point. I got a bit excited, aint used that word in years.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:47

Astagfirullah, i think i should clarify my views......my anger overrided what ive been taught

Gayness and whatever term they like to use, is a disease created by society......we should hate that, and try to combact it in an Islamic manner

condemning these people achieves nothing

i suppose we should help them realise the wrong and offer whatever support....especially after reading that story by MS about the woman who came back to the straight path.

hate the sin, not the sinner

these people are misguided, Allah swt knows there fate, i pray they all realise the wrong and return to the path of Allah swt

if not, May Allah swt be thier judge

my homophobic nature is due to upbringin, i find it hard to accept i shouldnt attack them - but i suppose i wouldnt be a good muslim if i did!!! i however in no way accept it, or agree with anythin to do with it

so that meeting for the assault is off now 😂

MuslimSister — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:50

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]Astagfirullah, i think i should clarify my views......my anger overrided what ive been taught

Gayness and whatever term they like to use, is a disease created by society......we should hate that, and try to combact it in an Islamic manner

condemning these people achieves nothing

i suppose we should help them realise the wrong and offer whatever support....especially after reading that story by MS about the woman who came back to the straight path.

hate the sin, not the sinner

these people are misguided, Allah swt knows there fate, i pray they all realise the wrong and return to the path of Allah swt

if not, May Allah swt be thier judge

my homophobic nature is due to upbringin, i find it hard to accept i shouldnt attack them - but i suppose i wouldnt be a good muslim if i did!!! i however in no way accept it, or agree with anythin to do with it

so that meeting for the assault is off now :lol:[/quote]

Wow. Very, VERY well said.

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:53

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"]
so that meeting for the assault is off now :lol:[/quote]

What the hell? Thats not good manners bruv. You invite and then the host himself aint gonna turn up, bad form, bad form.

But actually ditto to what Hayder just posted.

But what I will say is that if after giving them the correct info they wish to continue in being the devils men then they must be condemned in the strongest of terms. It is important to note the strong view that islaam takes on this issue.

If sodomites have been caught and convicted the death penalty becomes upon them. Convicted sodomites are not deemed worthy to live, they are to be exterminated. This is the seriousness of their abomination.

Sirus — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:56

[quote="Med"][quote="Hayder on Holiday"]
so that meeting for the assault is off now :lol:[/quote]

What the hell? Thats not good manners bruv. You invite and then the host himself aint gonna turn up, bad form, bad form.

But actually ditto to what Hayder just posted.

But what I will say is that if after giving them the correct info they wish to continue in being the devils men then they must be condemned in the strongest of terms. It is important to note the strong view that islaam takes on this issue.

If sodomites have been caught and convicted the death penalty becomes upon them. Convicted sodomites are not deemed worthy to live, they are to be exterminated. This is the seriousness of their abomination.[/quote]

lol....bro, we can hook up to assault someone else....!! 😂

if they dont choose the correct path, only Allah swt knows whether they will repent - i wouldnt want to be the one sentencing them to death.

if they want to be gay, so be it - in thier own privacy, dont be loud and proud, dont tell us, dont spread it, dont even look at me etc etc - you get the point

Medarris — Mon, 23 Jan 2006 - 21:59

[quote="Hayder on Holiday"] dont even look at me etc etc - you get the point[/quote]

lol.

Bruv, you aint that good looking. Im the one who needs to watch out.

It aint easy being this good-looking, infact in some ways its a curse but I struggle on.