Shirk and Bid'a - What are they?

[quote="aqdas.co.uk"]A mureed of Huzur Muhaddith al-A'zam al-Hind has compiled a book which is a debate on the correct definitions of Shirk and Bid'a.

This book has shown how the Wahabi definitions are unacceptable. Please download the book at

http://www.sunniport.com/portal/dload.php?action=file&file_id=245

or http://www.aqdas.co.uk[/quote]
o puhleez. cant we leave this stuff for the scholars to discuss? :roll:

Yes, we have. This is the result.

The people here know their aqeedah.

If they disagree, they will not be convinced by a book on the 'net.

I cannot see any point of discussing such a topic. All it will lead to is a flamewar.

I would avoid discussing aqeedah in general.

However if someone brings up a specific point, you are free to discuss that point. Such discussions do arise, just don't preempt them.